Secret Santa vs white elephant: which gift exchange to pick

Updated November 16, 2026

Secret Santa gives each person one assigned person to buy for, chosen at random and kept secret. White elephant has no assignments: everyone brings one wrapped gift to a shared pile, then players take turns opening a new one or stealing one that's already open. Kris Kringle is simply another name for Secret Santa.

Secret Santa

  • How it works: names are drawn so everyone buys for exactly one person, and nobody gets themselves.
  • Best for: families, friend groups and teams who know each other.
  • The gift: personal, picked for one person.
  • What you need: a fair, private draw. Name Draw does this with one link.

White elephant

  • How it works: one gift each, a shared pile, numbered turns, open or steal.
  • Best for: large or mixed groups, parties, offices where people don't know each other well.
  • The gift: general, often funny. It has to suit anyone.
  • What you need: a way to number the turns, and agreed rules on how many times a gift can be stolen.

Kris Kringle

The same as Secret Santa, under the name used in Australia and parts of the UK and Ireland. See the Kris Kringle draw.

How to choose

  • Do people know each other well? Secret Santa.
  • Is it a big or mixed group? White elephant.
  • Will everyone be in the same room? White elephant needs that. Secret Santa works remotely too.
  • Do you want a laugh or a thoughtful gift? White elephant for the laugh, Secret Santa for the thought.

Start a Secret Santa draw

Open Name Draw